Insanity

April 5th, 2011 - Uncategorized - 21 Comments »

This is guest post from my friend Jon Arena. He’s guest posted here before about a grievance we can all relate to – annoying concert fans. Today, he gives people who add to the definition of a word the reaming they deserve. Take it away Jon.
____

INSANE.

We’ve all heard it countless times, whether from pastors, politicians, coaches, or really smart celebrities — “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” It is? Since when? When I look in the dictionary, I find the following:

-A deranged state of the mind usually occurring as a specific disorder (as schizophrenia)

-Such unsoundness of mind or lack of understanding as prevents one from having the mental capacity required by law to enter into a particular relationship, status, or transaction or as removes one from criminal or civil responsibility

-Extreme folly or unreasonableness

I should point out now that I can’t remember the last time I actually flipped through the pages of a physical dictionary and learned (or verified) the definition of a word. How far we’ve come!!!

I’m not going to pretend to have mastered the English language and all of its wonderful subtleties, but I also don’t make speeches hinging on completely fabricated definitions.

Can you imagine what this culturally accepted definition of insanity would look like in a courtroom?

“As you know, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, my client is pleading insanity in this case. He murdered his first victim and, of course, she died. He murdered his second victim, and again the deceased died. He was certain that murdering his third victim would not result in loss of life, but once again was astounded to discover that his victim passed away. You see, he was expecting that sooner or later, one of his murder victims would actually live. My client is obviously insane. Thank you.”

I heard a college basketball coach this weekend whining about how his players weren’t rebounding like they knew they should, and how this was an obvious example of insanity. Even if the “new” definition was actually correct [and I think I’ve established that it’s not], it still doesn’t make any sense to use in that situation. Do you think your players actually believed that by not rebounding, they would score more points and hold their opponents to less points? If so, you have a bunch of morons playing for you.

Just once I would love for a post-game press conference to include the following:

“Uhhh, coach, a few minutes ago you said that ‘the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.’ Do you realize that that is demonstrably false?  Do you think it might have been better to describe your players as ‘stupid,’ ‘dull,’ or ‘unintelligent,’ as opposed to ‘insane’?”

Recently I expressed my frustration about this trend to my good friend John Joseph Osborn, and he quipped that my continued frustration was insane.  I didn’t find that joke funny at all.

Agree? Disagree? Are there any other words/definitions that frustrate you?

  • Tyler Stanton

    Coupon.
    I've yet to be confident in it's pronunciation.

  • http://guidetowomen.wordpress.com/ Sharideth Smith

    irony.

    most misused word e.v.e.r.

    • Tyler Stanton

      you and tripp should talk about that. he's atlanta's local irony-misuse police.tyler stanton

      • http://guidetowomen.wordpress.com/ Sharideth Smith

        does he have the authority to arrest alanis morissette? because i would really like that.

  • Chris

    Religion.
    Popular preachers, "seeker-friendly" churches, and others use a false definition of this word that turns it into something negative.

  • Matt

    Isn't doing the same thing and expecting different results "Extreme folly or unreasonableness"?

    • Jon

      Certainly doing the same thing and expecting different results could be described as an unreasonable practice, but it doesn't make it the definition of insanity. Expecting a Lexus dealer to sell me a brand new car for $100 would also certainly be described as unreasonable, but no one is suggesting that the definition of insanity is expecting a Lexus dealer to sell me a brand new car for $100.

  • clintm

    That definition is Albert Einsteins definition… not Webster's definition.

    • clintm

      google it

    • Joseph

      Albert Einstein, who do you think you are? You just take a word that already has a definition and think you can give it a new one? Then you tell all sorts of public figures to use your definition as if it's the real one? Just because your hair makes you look insane (by which I mean you look like a person who does the same thing over and over again expecting different results,) doesn't give you the right to usurp the authority of Webster.

  • Daniel

    Hilarious. I’m all about people using words incorrectly.

    The most consistent one I see, though, is definitely “literally.”

    “She helps me so much, she’s literally my arms and legs.”

    “And if you keep emotionally doing that, you heart can literally turn into a heart of stone.”

    Etc etc. They’re insane.

  • casey

    I could hug you for writing this b/c I've been thinking this for years. The first time I heard someone give that definition of insanity I thought, "wow that's deep." Then, the second time I decided to look it up & found that nowhere did it say anything like that. Now every time I hear someone give it in a speech, sermon, talk, etc I want to ask them to get the dictionary out & find that definition in there. I restrain myself though.

    • Jon

      Keep fighting the good fight, Casey. I'm glad to know I'm not the only one who finds this annoying.

  • Bryan

    im still confused whether "niche" rhymes with mitch or quiche.

    • Tyler Stanton

      Hahahahahaha.__________tyler stantonSent from my new Palm Pilot.

    • Jon

      Webster.com has only one pronunciation sound byte, and it's the mitch variety. Coupon, however, has two acceptable pronunciations. I got really self conscious about "February" last year and was relieved to discover that there are two acceptable pronunciations.

  • Mandi

    "Literally." I hear people say all the time that they "literally" did something that isn't even possible.

    • Jared

      And worse than that is when they pronounce it "litrally."

  • http://twitter.com/thealitybites @thealitybites

    "Like".

    It's become a cross between "Um" and "Smurf", where someone needs to stop and think about what they're saying next.

    "And so, like, I was just all like over it, like, y'know?"

    Argh.

  • http://180tampa.com Jerry White

    So based on this 'new' definition, are all the people doing the newest cardio regiment called 'insanity' expecting to get fatter?

    • Jon

      Jerry-yours was my favorite comment. Not that you should care, but I wanted to let you know.